Free Severed Finger Pattern & Tutorial
Once upon a midnight dreary, a witch sat stitching, weak and weary.
She had lost her trusty potion stirrer—her favorite bony finger!
So she stitched herself a new one… with fabric, thread, and a touch of spooky style.
Lucky for you, you don’t need a bubbling cauldron or dark magic—just a bit of fleece, stuffing, and today’s free pattern. Whether you’re decking out your haunted house, accessorizing your plush cauldron, or creeping out trick-or-treaters, this severed finger plushie is frightfully fun (and free!).
This pattern includes:
1. Top Finger Piece (with darts for shape) 2. Bottom Finger Piece (with oval hole for bending)
3. End Piece (to close the base) 4. Nail Piece (for that creepy manicure)
Supplies You’ll Need
Fabric Suggestions
Finger Flesh: Fleece, felt, or flannel (pale, grey, or zombie-green shades are extra spooky).
Nail: Stiff felt, vinyl, or faux leather for a glossy nail finish.
Step-by-Step Tutorial
Cut fabric pieces
Pin each pattern piece on single layered fabric and cut one of each.
Attach the Nail
Place the nail at the top of the finger top fabric and stitch along the bottom.
Sew the stitches.
Using black crochet thread and needle, sew “stitches” to the top hand as desired.
Sew the Darts
Fold each dart with fabric right sides together on the top finger piece and stitch closed to give the finger its rounded shape.
With fabric right sides together, pin and stitch the dart at the top of the bottom finger.
With fabric right sides together, fold along the hole in the center. Pin and stitch along the outside of the hole.
Join Top & Bottom Finger
Stitch the top finger piece to the bottom finger piece all the way around, leaving the bottom open.
Add the Bottom Cap
Sew the bottom cap piece to the finger, leaving a small opening.
Turn & Stuff
Turn the finger right side out.
Stuff with polyfill until firm but bendable.
Close the Finger
Hand stitch the opening closed with a ladder stitch.
Suggested Add-Ons
💀 A few drops of red fabric paint for “blood” at the base.
🧛 Add a spooky nail polish effect with metallic or glow-in-the-dark fabric paint.
🎃 Place inside a trick-or-treat bowl for jump scares!
FAQs
Q: Can I make different sizes?
Yes! Print the pattern at different scales—smaller for witch fingers, larger for monster claws.
Q: How do I make the finger bend more realistically?
The oval hole in the bottom piece allows for a bend. You can also insert a thin wire inside before stuffing.
Q: What’s the best way to get a “bloody” look?
Use red fabric paint or a dab of hot glue mixed with red acrylic paint.
Q: Can I hand sew instead of machine sewing?
Yes!
It looks like a buffet where asking what anything is made from would be considered rude.
Sew a whole handful of fingers and scatter them across your Halloween table, tuck them into your cauldron display, or give them out as creepy-cute party favors. Whether you’re stitching for fun, fright, or frightful fun, this free pattern is a finger-tastic addition to your Halloween crafts.
Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase something through one of these links, Sew Cute Patterns may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Shop Patterns | sewing tutorials | sewing blog | Shop sewing supplies