Stuffed Animal Eyes: 7 Creative Ways to Bring Your Plushie to Life 👀
The eyes might just be the window to your plushie's soul—and there are so many adorable ways to give your stuffed animals a little sparkle, silliness, or snooze! Whether you're crafting a cuddly creature, spooky critter, or sleepy sloth, here are 7 creative (and beginner-friendly!) suggestions for making stuffed animal eyes—plus some favorite tools and supplies linked below.
1. Plastic Safety Eyes
These classic plastic animal eyes come with shank backs and locking washers, making them a secure and professional option for plush toys. They’re available in tons of sizes and colors.
🛒 Try these:
✨ Tip: Use a sharp awl tool to make a clean hole in your fabric for easy placement.
2. Button Eyes
Perfect for a handmade or vintage look, buttons are a great way to personalize your plush. Look for flat or slightly domed buttons and securely hand-stitch them in place.
🧵 Great choice for dolls, bunnies, or Halloween plushies needing a quirky vibe!
3. Googly Eyes
These wiggly plastic eyes are super fun—perfect for silly monsters or DIY toy kits for kids. Just use hot glue to attach them once your plush is assembled.
4. Plastic Jewels
Want your stuffie to sparkle? Plastic gems are a fabulous (and unexpected!) option. Use a low-temp glue gun or fabric glue to attach them.
🧙♀️ Great for dragons, fantasy creatures, or witch-themed plush pals!
5. Felt Fabric Eyes
Felt is one of the easiest materials to cut and glue, making it perfect for custom eye shapes—think sleepy lashes, oval cartoon eyes, or spooky spirals.
🛒 Rainbow Felt Sheet Pack – 42 Colors
🛒 Fabric Glue for Felt & Plush
✂️ Bonus: Stitch the edges for extra security (and cuteness)!
6. Pom Poms
Fluffy and fun! You can use larger pom poms for eye bases, then add smaller ones or plastic safety eyes for pupils. Great for whimsical characters and plush toys with personality.
🧸 Try it with bears, aliens, or oversized plush creatures!
7. Embroidered Eyes
Embroidery adds a charming handmade touch. Use a backstitch for sleeping eyes, or satin stitch for solid round eyes. This option is safe for babies and adds a beautiful finish.
🛒 Embroidery Floss Set with needles
🌙 Great for bedtime plush books or soft toys for infants!
Final Stitch: Which Eye Style is Right for You?
When choosing how to make your plushie's eyes, think about the age group, theme, and overall personality of your stuffed animal. There's no wrong answer—just lots of fun ways to experiment and make it yours!
🧵 Shop Supplies
Everything you need for crafting cute critter eyes:
✅ Plastic safety eyes
✅ Buttons and pom poms
✅ Felt sheets and fabric glue
✅ Embroidery floss and tools
✅ Googly eyes, rhinestones
Sewing Classes to Level Up Your Skills!
Check out classes from creativebug and craftsy for sewing tutorials that’ll make you a sewing superstar in no time! From beginner basics to advanced techniques, there's something for everyone.
Affiliate Disclosure:
This post may contain affiliate links. That means I may earn a small commission—at no extra cost to you—if you decide to make a purchase through one of the links.
Shop PDF Sewing Patterns
Sew Cute Patterns | Etsy