Eye Spy: How to Choose the Best Eyes for Your Handmade Toys 👀

The eyes are the windows to a toy’s soul—or at least, they bring your handmade creations to life! Choosing the right eyes for your project can be a daunting task, but don't worry—I've got you covered. Whether you're crafting a cuddly plushie or a whimsical doll, this guide will help you decide between safety eyes, embroidered eyes, and felt eyes. Let’s dive in!

Safety Eyes

What Are They?
Plastic eyes with a shank and washer backing, often with a shiny or glossy finish. They mimic a realistic or cartoony look, depending on the style.

Pros:

• Durable and secure when properly attached.

• Available in a variety of sizes, shapes, and colors.

• Great for toys meant for older kids or decorative use.

Cons:

• Not recommended for toys made for children under 3 years old due to choking hazards.

• Can be tricky to install once the backing is in place—it’s a commitment!

Pro Tip:
To ensure a snug fit, always check that the washer is securely fastened. A small dab of fabric glue on the post can provide extra security.

Embroidered Eyes

What Are They?
Hand or machine-stitched details that create eyes directly on the fabric.

Pros:

• Soft and safe for all ages, especially babies.

• Completely customizable in size, shape, and expression.

• Adds a handmade, artisanal touch to your toys.

Cons:

• Time-consuming to create, especially intricate designs.

• Requires some embroidery skills.

Pro Tip:
Use an embroidery hoop to keep your fabric taut and choose high-contrast thread colors to make those eyes pop!

Felt Eyes

What Are They?
Cutouts from felt fabric glued or sewn onto the toy's surface.

Pros:

• Incredibly versatile for fun, cartoonish designs.

• Quick to make and easy to attach.

• Affordable and available in a rainbow of colors.

Cons:

• Can peel or fray over time if not securely sewn or glued.

• Not as durable as other options for high-use toys.

Pro Tip:
Stitch around the edges of felt pieces after gluing for extra durability, especially if the toy will be played with frequently.

Tips for Securing Toy Eyes

1. Test Placement First: Before committing to an attachment method, use pins or a light adhesive to preview eye placement.

2. Safety First: For toys for small children, avoid small parts and go for embroidered or felt options.

3. Double-Check Durability: Give the eyes a tug to ensure they are secure—better safe than sorry!

4. Finishing Touches: Add highlights or accents with fabric paint or thread to give your toy extra personality.

Choosing the right eyes for your handmade toys is a fun way to bring your projects to life. Whether you’re going for playful, quirky, or lifelike, there’s an option for every style.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting our blog!

Shop Patterns 
Shop Sew Cute Patterns | Visit Our Etsy Store

Shop Patterns | sewing tutorials | sewing blog | Shop sewing supplies