Crafty Eyes: Top Tips for Attaching Plastic Eyes to Plushies

Sewing Tutorials
Written By Diana Cison
 

Plastic eyes can take your plushies from cute to absolutely adorable — but only if they’re securely attached! If you’ve ever struggled with getting those little eyes in place without feeling like you need superhuman strength, this post is for you. Grab your plush project, and let’s dive into some tried-and-true tips for attaching plastic eyes with ease.

Why Plastic Eyes?

Plastic eyes (often called safety eyes) are a popular choice for plush makers because they’re durable, come in a variety of styles, and provide a polished, professional look. They’re especially great for toys intended for older children or display items. For toddlers or babies, embroidered eyes are recommended for added safety.

Tools & Supplies You’ll Need

  • Plastic safety eyes (size and style of your choice)

  • Washers (usually included with safety eyes)

  • Awl or small scissors

  • Needle-nose pliers (optional but handy)

  • Fabric marking pen

  • Your in-progress plushie creation

Tips for Attaching Plastic Eyes

1. Plan Your Placement

Before anything else, mark where you want your eyes to go. Use a fabric marking pen to make light dots on your fabric. Double-check symmetry by measuring the distance from the nose or centerline of the plush. It’s worth the extra minute to avoid the dreaded wonky-eye look.

2. Make a Small Starter Hole

Depending on the fabric thickness, you may need to create a tiny hole for the eye post. An awl works wonders for this! Gently pierce the fabric to create just enough space for the post to slide through. If you’re working with thick fleece or multiple layers, small embroidery scissors can help.

3. Secure the Washer

The washer is what locks the eye into place and keeps it secure. Push the eye post through the hole, then slide the washer onto the back of the post. Apply firm pressure until you hear or feel a satisfying snap. If the washer is stubborn, use needle-nose pliers to press it down evenly.

4. Use Heat for Stubborn Washers

Some washers, especially larger sizes, can be hard to push on. To make it easier, warm the washer in hot water for a few seconds (not boiling!). This softens the plastic slightly, making it more pliable.

5. Work Before Stuffing

Attach the eyes before you stuff your plushie. It’s much easier to maneuver the fabric and secure the washers when the piece is flat. Once the eyes are attached, you can proceed to stuffing and sewing the rest of your plush.

6. Double Check the Fit

Once your eyes are attached, give them a gentle tug to ensure they’re securely locked in place. If anything feels loose, now’s the time to fix it. Better safe than sorry!

Bonus Tips for Customizing Plastic Eyes

  • Paint Your Eyes: Add unique details by painting the backs of clear safety eyes with acrylic paint for a custom look.

  • Add Eyelashes or Eyelids: Use embroidery to give your plushie extra character.

  • Mix and Match Sizes: Try using different sizes of eyes for quirky, whimsical creations.

Troubleshooting Common Issues

  • The Eye Won’t Fit Through the Fabric: Double-check your starter hole. It may need to be slightly bigger, but be careful not to overdo it.

  • The Washer Won’t Snap On: Try warming the washer or use pliers for extra leverage.

  • The Eye Feels Loose: Ensure the washer is pressed all the way down. If the fabric is too thin, consider reinforcing it with a small piece of felt.

With these tips, you’ll be a plastic-eye pro in no time. Ready to put your skills to the test? Check out our latest sewing patterns featuring adorable plushies that will have you grinning ear to ear.

Shop Animal Eyes

Check out these shops for an adorable selection of animal eyes!


Shop Patterns with Personality — because every plushie deserves a little charm. 💖
Shop Sew Cute Patterns | Visit Our Etsy Store

 
Diana Cison
Previous

Sew This! Plush Snake Sewing Pattern
Next

Pins or Clips? Let’s Tackle the Great Sewing Debate!